{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Make a Shift: Negotiation Opportunities for Buyers

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

After an unprecedented run of over three years where average homes in the United States consistently fetched prices higher than the previous year, that trend has finally come to a halt. Recent national statistics from October reveal that the median home sale prices have dipped slightly below those from one year prior, marking the first annual decrease since spring 2023. Simultaneously, the inventory of homes for sale has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales are at their lowest levels in more than ten years (excluding the early pandemic), and approximately 20% of property listings have seen price reductions.

However, borrowing money has become pricier again. The average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has jumped back into the mid-7% territory over the last week, following a brief period of improvement. Thus, even though buyers are now gaining some leverage at the negotiating table, the strain on monthly payments remains a concern for many households.

This unique situation has created an opportune time for negotiations. With sellers dealing with fewer offers and experiencing longer times on the market, the list price and terms of any offer may be more of an opening bid than a final figure. If you're in the market for a new home this winter, consider these points for potential negotiation and how to address them with both your agent and lender.

Interpreting a Minor Price Decrease

A national decline of just under half a percent is not indicative of a market crash, nor does it imply that every area is experiencing falling prices. Certain high-value coastal areas, with limited inventory, continue to see price hikes, whereas several major urban areas in the southern and western regions have faced declines of several percentage points compared to last year. Local market conditions are far more significant than national averages.

This shift in the national data suggests a change in leverage within the market. With homes lingering longer on the market and a greater number of listings vying for a limited pool of buyers, sellers tend to be more amenable to negotiation. This openness can manifest itself not only in the price but also in the terms of the sale.

Price is Just One Negotiation Point

While many buyers fixate on the purchase price itself, in an environment of high mortgage rates, the overall monthly payment and the cash required at closing often take precedence. A discount of a few thousand dollars on the price leads to only a marginal reduction in your loan amount. Strategically adjusting how that money is utilized can yield better financial outcomes. Here are some common discussion points in a slower market:

  • A lower purchase price compared to the listing price
  • A seller credit to cover some closing costs
  • Completion of repairs prior to closing, or a credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller assistance in buying down your mortgage interest rate
  • A closing date or move-in timeline tailored to your needs
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings with the home

Your real estate agent will have insights on how sellers in your area are responding and can guide you on which points to emphasize in your proposals. The goal is to prioritize items that will make a significant difference for you, rather than attempting to request everything.

Credits for Closing Costs Can Alleviate Financial Strain

Typically, closing costs range from a few percent of the loan amount, in addition to the down payment. For many first-time buyers, accumulating enough cash for these costs poses a significant challenge. A seller credit can alleviate some of these burdens by reducing the amount of cash you need at closing.

Keep in mind that there are limits involving seller contributions based on loan programs, typically between 3% and 9% of the purchase price, depending on the loan type and the down payment size. Additionally, the credit can't exceed the actual closing costs incurred. Consult your lender early to find out what is allowable under your specific loan parameters so that any request in your offer complies with regulations.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates climbing above 7%, one valuable option that a seller can provide is assistance with your mortgage interest rate. There are primarily two methods to achieve this.

A permanent buydown entails the use of discount points paid at closing to secure a lower rate for the entirety of the loan. Each point typically costs 1% of the loan amount and the reduction it affords in the interest rate varies by lender and market conditions. If you plan to hold onto the loan for an extended period, a permanent buydown could be financially rewarding.

A temporary buydown allows for lower payments at the onset for the first year or two. For example, in a common arrangement, the rate might be reduced by two percentage points during the initial year and one percentage point in the second year, eventually reverting to the full rate. On a $350,000 30-year mortgage at around 7.34%, monthly payments would be approximately $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the payment for the first year would drop to around $1,952, rising to about $2,176 in the second year, before returning to the full payment in year three. Covering this buy down could cost a seller just over $8,000, which might be preferable to reducing the price by a similar sum.

However, a temporary buydown should not be viewed as a long-term solution. You must be able to handle the full payment once the promotional period ends, and lenders usually assess you based on the complete interest rate. Should rates decline later, refinancing could be a possibility, but it's uncertain when or if this will occur.

Don't Overlook Inspections to Stay Competitive

During the frantic market conditions, many buyers would waive inspections or limit their requests in order to win bidding wars. In a more temperate market, there is less urgency to forgo these essential protections. Conducting a thorough home inspection will provide clarity on the condition of critical systems such as the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical components, and the foundation prior to making a commitment.

If any issues arise from the inspection, your agent can assist in determining whether to request repairs, negotiate for a price adjustment, or accept a credit. Choosing a credit can sometimes simplify the process since you control who handles the repairs and how they are completed; however, the right approach depends on the specific issue at hand and your loan conditions.

Prepare Your Financing in Advance

Having strong negotiating capabilities is of little use if your financing is unstable. When comparing two offers, a seller will generally prefer the buyer they believe is most likely to successfully close the sale. Before entering the search seriously, pursue a thorough pre-approval instead of a quick pre-qualification. Understand your comfortable monthly payment limits rather than just the maximum loan amount, and compare loan estimates from various lenders. It's also beneficial to ask how each lender would handle seller credits or buydowns, ensuring clarity without surprises down the line.

Key Questions to Discuss with Your Agent

  • What is the average time homes are staying on the market in this neighborhood, and how frequently are prices reduced?
  • Would a price reduction, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown be the most beneficial for my finances?
  • How do the condition and history of this particular home influence potential negotiations?
  • What contingencies should I maintain in my offer for protection?

Final Thoughts

A market that is softening doesn't equate to cheap buying opportunities, especially given that mortgage rates are on the rise again. Nevertheless, it does afford well-prepared buyers a greater chance to negotiate terms that suit their financial requirements. By securing solid financing, establishing clear priorities, and collaborating with your agent and lender, you may discover ways to secure arrangements that were previously unthinkable just a year or two back.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message